Cobb Tells Naharkey's Story

          Today's TulsaWorld newspaper has a guest columnist's piece on an appalling land grab 100+ years ago in Creek Nation, Indian Territory. No, not THE big land grab when the U.S. Government broke its zillioneth contract with indigenous peoples by declaring their territory the 46th state in 1907. This is about a woman cheated of control of her very own allotment. 

          Written by a former Tulsan and a forever-Okie, Russell Cobb adapted the story of Millie Naharkey from his new book, The Great Oklahoma Swindle: Race, Religion, and Lies in America’s Weirdest State. 

https://t.co/CNXx8iOFOC?amp=1

          (I pray my link leads you to the article. Holler, if not). 

          Because I can't wait for Prime to bring Cobb's book to my doorstep (we ARE practicing "social distance" in lieu of Covid-19), I plugged Millie Naharkey's name into Newspapers.com.

          From the front page of an October 5, 1922 newspaper:



          Because front pages of old newspapers rock, here's a partial shot from the same paper. Look who was en route to Muskogee that week. See "Comrades Attention!" at the top:



          I was happy to learn from Cobb's article of Millie Naharkey's hard-fought legal victory against Charles Page, head of the corporation named "Sand Springs Home." Good for her!  Although she saw little of the profit from the land thanks to her guardians at 1st National Bank of Tulsa. Imagine what the Bank's lawyers hourly fee was to represent themselves in that lawsuit, I mean, Ms. Naharkey.

          Having her repeatedly declared "an incompetent Indian" before a judge and then stealing her inheritance!  Reminds me of Wells Fargo's recent fine for twice setting up fake accounts under customer's names so it could profit by moving money around--without knowledge or approval from customers, FFS.  

          Have you ever wished bankers could be tarred and feathered?

https://law.justia.com/cases/oklahoma/supreme-court/1936/23023.html

         
          If you also read Newspapers.com, here's the 1922 article's link:  https://www.newspapers.com/image/608081786/
 

A New Bride, A Heart Attack, And A Contested Will

          On April 12, 1912, John H. Coffee of Kingston, Oklahoma, and Ina Hight of Denison, Texas, were married. A widower who had lost his wife Nancy (James) Coffee in 1895, this was John's second marriage. He was 60. It was the bride's third marriage. She was 40.


          I don't know where they were married, but the license was filed in Grayson County, Texas--just over the Oklahoma border.  Source: Texas, Select County Marriage Records, 1837-2015 (database) via Ancestry.com/


          Born Ina Marie Beasley, her second husband, James Robert Hight, had recently lost his wife, Ruth Ella (Beasley). Yes, Ruth was Ina's older sister.  James was left with the care of their six children. I i
magine his concern as a father was a factor in his January 1, 1909 marriage to Ina Marie Greer. 


          It was not uncommon for siblings to marry widowed spouses of family. Ina brought with her the three young children from her first husband, Oscar Gilbert Greer.  One year after marrying, the 1910 Federal Census finds James and Ina living in Comanche County, Oklahoma with their combined ten children. See them on this census page:


MEANWHILE BACK IN LITTLE DIXIE: (Yes, southeast Oklahoma is called that)  The next I find Ina Hight is in 1912 Marshall County after marrying my 2xGreat-Gramps. John has a grocery, a restaurant, and a candy store in Kingston. His obit later indicated "Mrs. Iona Hight" was from Denison, Texas. If accurate, then Ina somehow moved from Comanche County, Oklahoma to northeastern Texas. Would love to know how she met John Coffee. 

          Here are two images from the 1913 Polk City Directory for Kingston, Oklahoma showing John's restaurant and grocery:



          Sadly, their new marriage was shortened, as my maternal 2xG-Grandfather suffered a heart attack in early November 1913. He died two weeks later. Ina notified John's two adult children: John, who lived in New Mexico, and Elizabeth in Gravois Mills, Missouri. John's obituary made the front page of The Kingston Messenger.  The WEEKLY paper, mind you!
 


Can't read it?  It says:   A PIONEER CITIZEN PASSES AWAY -- Death of J.H. Coffee After an Illness of a Short Time.

          Last Monday night, after an illness of about two weeks, Mr. J.H. COFFEE, one of our oldest citizens, laid down his        life's burdens and went to his last rest. He was well thought of by all our people, a man of honor, integrity and uprightness. He was loyal to the church of his faith, the Christian church. He was born in Mt. Sterling, Ky., March 9, 1850, going from there to Missouri in his early manhood, where he was married to Miss Nancy C. JAMES, Sept. 1, 1872. Two children were born to them, John COFFEE, now residing in New Mexico, and Mrs. Lizzie PAGE, now living in Missouri. His wife died at their Missouri home August 9, 1895, soon after which he came to this section and located near here. About eleven years ago he purchased property in town and opened up the business which he conducted to the time of his death. April 12, 1912 he was married to Mrs. Iona HIGHT of Denison, who survives him. He was buried Tuesday afternoon in the cemetery here. The funeral services were held in the new church of which he was so proud, Rev. J.H. LAWSON of Denison, conducting the services. Mr. John COFFEE, of New Mexico, and little daughter, and Mrs. Martha EDMON, his sister, and her daughter, Mrs. Ida THOMPSON, of Texarkana, Ark., Mr. Tom COFFEE and family of Madill, and Joe COFFEE, of Calera, nephews of deceased, were here to attend the funeral. 
__________________

         
          They came to Oklahoma for their dad's funeral. Upon learning of John's will leaving them $2 each, they promptly hired lawyers to contest the will.
But after a few weeks, it ended well. John's children dismissed their claim. 

          Descendants may find these 19 pages interesting, as they are actual copies from the court's probate file. Woo hoo! Click on each page, and move the horizontal scroll bar to the right to see all 19. Errors and all! White Out wasn't yet invented.



          Meet the gentlemen in question:  John H. Coffee, born March 9, 1852, and died November 17, 1913



          I'm grateful to Aunt Nancy for sharing her worn copy of his obit long ago. It gave me the clues necessary to begin my search. And I so appreciate RaeJean for contacting me this summer. What a thrill it was to find a message from Ina's descendant! She helped knock down a genealogy "brick wall" of many years.



          

Update To Previous Post On Lizzie Coffee Page

Months ago I wrote of my Mom's Grand-Aunt Lizzie
http://treepig.posthaven.com/lizzie-coffee-page-daughter-of-john-h-and-nancy-james-coffee  and how we lost touch with her family.

Well, I learned of her daughter Monta's final resting place. And it is in the same cemetery as our beloved Aunt Helen. Fancy that! I hope to find Lizzie's burial place soon.

See Monta Belle (Page) Webster's page on Findagrave:

http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=141143279

(Hmm, wish I knew how to turn that choppy looking URL into something I could give a subtitle.)

I obtained Aunt Lizzie's date of death from here:

Source: Ancestry.com. California, Death Index, 1940-1997. 

Lizzie (Coffee) Page, Daughter of Nancy James and John Coffee

I have looked for years for the death date of my maternal Great-Grand-Aunt Lizzie, and found it just last night. THANK YOU, ANCESTRY DOT COM! This was a minor brick wall for me. No one I spoke to in the last 18 years knew what had happened to Aunt Lizzie in her dotage. Or where she had been buried. Our Great Aunt Helen told me she thought Lizzie had died/buried in Missouri. My Dear Old Mom (are you reading this, LOL!) spoke fondly of how her Aunt Lizzie was a lot of fun and quite energetic when she (as a child) last saw her some time in the 1940s. She recalls how Lizzie played with her younger sister Nancy. 

When Elizabeth was born December 1, 1873 in Versailles, Missouri, her father, John Hanna Coffee, was 21. Her mother, Nancy (James) Coffee, was 19. By the time of the 1880 Federal Census, the family had moved to Cooke County, near Sherman, Texas. Lizzie is seven years old, and her little brother, John Willis Coffee, is five. I know of no other siblings. Why did this family move hundreds of miles from their central Missouri roots? A new railroad had just connected Missouri to Texas. The MKT or "Katy" railway went through Indian Territory, and my father's Ackley relatives once worked on building this same railroad outside of Tulsa. I can only imagine that Lizzie's parents took the Katy north and south a few times rather than risk riding a wagon through a very untamed Cherokee Nation. Think True Grit here. Lizzie had a two or three ex-Confederate soldier uncles who also settled in northern Texas, so this young Coffee family would have lived near "kin" at their Sherman, Texas home.

By 1894 the family is back in Morgan County, Missouri where Lizzie's mom, Nancy Coffee, dies in early August, at age 40. Her obit doesn't mention a cause of death. Perhaps the family returned to Missouri because Nancy was ill and wanted to be near family?  I can only imagine her husband and two children were devastated. I have seen a transcription of an obit from a cousin-researcher who indicated it had been published in a local paper in 1894. Her tombstone, however, has an 1895 death date. Nancy had plenty of siblings. I hope someday to connect with a researcher descendant of this James family who might have a letter or family Bible indicating a cause of death. While Missouri has a great vital records' web presence via its Secretary of State, I don't yet find a death certificate for her--if one even exists. 

Soon after, in April of 1897, a 23 year old Lizzie marries a 58 year old widower, Jerome Page. Jerome already has six children (the youngest, age six) and Lizzie bears him another three: Monta Belle, five months later; Albert, in 1900; and Roy in 1902. Successive censuses find Lizzie living in rural Morgan County up until she appears as "widowed" in the 1940 Census, living with her daughter's family.

This is the last I find of Aunt Lizzie until her death in Los Angeles on December 5, 1953--four days after her 80th birthday. Have you memories of her or recall stories told to you about John Willis Coffee's big sister, Elizabeth (Coffee) Page? Please share